Product Showdown: What are the Best Windows for Your Home?

Not all windows and doors are the same.  Each has its own unique set of functions and equally interesting design characteristics.  And when you think of all the different types of windows offered, including the various shapes, styles and materials, sometimes it’s helpful to do a bit of comparison shopping. 

So we thought, wouldn’t it be fun to introduce you to some options in somewhat of a unique context?  If you’re about to jump into a home improvement project and in the market for a quality window, let the games begin!
 
 

Casement Windows vs. Awning Windows

Often confused for one another, but unique in their own right respectively, these two window types are typically known as the “one with the crank handle.”  They also share another trait in that they’re both hinged windows that swing open or closed accordingly.  However, that’s where the similarities start to diverge.

The benefits of a casement window are significant, specifically due to its design.  For a traditional look that can blend into many different home designs, it’s a great option.  Plus, the ease of use factor is a huge plus.  As a result, you can use these windows in somewhat hard-to-reach places while optimizing the ability to open and close them easily. 

The Marvin Signature Modern Casement is a sleek and streamlined addition to any home design that favors big glass and open views.   

On the other hand, if it’s privacy and airflow you’re looking for, then an awning window might be the way to go.  You may see these windows integrated into home designs where natural light and ventilation are the goals, yet the see-through nature of a long casement window just won’t give you that added level of privacy an awning window can. 

One popular selection is the Ultimate Awning from Marvin.  Part of the Signature line, these windows are high performance and also have an optional motor-drive system for remote operation via the flick of a wall switch.  

Winner: The awning window is a clear candidate for those who have privacy concerns, but the fact that the casement window checks a lot of boxes gives it a slight edge if you’re looking for an all-around solution. 

Double Hung vs. Single Hung

These two windows are two of the most common especially in homes that were built from the early 17th century to today and are so similar yet have one major distinction that separates them. 

The double-hung window is personified by its sash operation.  With an upper and lower sash that can open, the ventilation options are very flexible.  Not to mention, cleaning is a breeze with both sashes able to tilt in for easy access which is key, especially on those second-floor elevations. 

The Andersen 400 Series Double-Hung Window is one of the best-selling windows on the market today and comes in a variety of exterior colors to match your home. 

The only difference between the single-hung and double-hung window is the fact that the single-hung only has one sash that’s operational (the lower), with a fixed upper sash.  

The Andersen 100 Series Single-Hung Window, made of Fibrex®, is budget-friendly and easy to operate. 

Winner: The Double-Hung for maximum ventilation; the Single-Hung for high value. 

Picture Window vs. Skylight

These two products are known for their ability to bring in a maximum amount of light into your home, whether at eye level or from above.  They also do a great job of creating a view in just about any dwelling.  

Picture windows are called as such because they’re usually featured in areas that frame a beautiful view.  And while most may think of them in terms of being fixed and non-operable there are models that have venting capabilities, like the Marvin Ultimate Venting Picture Window.  

Skylights or roof windows as they’re also known do a fantastic job of brightening up a room.  Plus, those that are operational have the added benefit of bringing in fresh air.  At WindowRama, we feature two superior brands of skylights – Supreme Skylights and Velux.  Available in various sizes, some also feature integrated window treatments to control the amount of sunlight. 

Winner: Tie

Bay Windows vs. Bow Windows 

The Bay and Bow Window are birds of the same feather.  Both are typically found in living rooms, dining rooms and kitchens, but can also find a spot in a bedroom if you have the space. 

A bay window is typically one fixed center window that is flanked by two fixed or operating windows like double-hungs or casements.  They also provide a surface for various decorations or can be used for additional seating.

A bow window on the other hand is usually a contiguous series of the same type of window assembled together on a curve, again typically a series of casement or double-hung windows.   

The Andersen 400 Series Bay & Bow Windows are available in a variety of configurations, and interior and exterior colors.  Check out this video we produced on the differences between the two.   

Winner: The bay window is probably slightly more popular, especially because you can sit on it while you enjoy the view, but the bow has its definite merit.  

Wood vs. Fiberglass vs. Vinyl

This round is a bit different and we’re going to focus on three of the most popular types of materials windows are made of these days. 

Wood windows are as classic as they are reliable.  The warmth of wood, combined with the fact you can paint or stain it to essentially match any decor, make it a go-to choice.  You can also find wood windows that are wrapped with various exterior casings, such as aluminum, to help them withstand the elements. 

Fiberglass is an attractive option, for both it’s durability and low maintenance qualities.  Plus, because fiberglass expands and contracts at the same rate as glass, they don’t suffer from structural integrity issues when exposed to drastic changes in temperature and moisture. 

Vinyl is not only value-engineered but extremely low maintenance so once installed, there’s very little upkeep needed to keep them looking like new.   

Winner: Wood nails it on look/feel, Fiberglass has it hands down on durability, and Vinyl takes the crown for low maintenance.
 
 

Polygon vs. Polygon?

How can one type compete against itself?  Easy.  With so many different shapes and sizes to consider, it all boils down to how drastic a design you’re looking to achieve.

And while you may think of these shapes in more modernistic architectural designs, keep in mind some of them can be found in homes that date back generations.  Perhaps you’re looking to integrate a statement wall into a remodeling project?  Or you may just need to find a replacement product for an existing window that’s beyond its useful life.  No matter the application, we have a solution to fit the bill. 

When it comes to shapes, the Kolbe Heritage Series features a variety of “geometrics” – from triangles and trapezoids to octagons and more. 

Winner: You, because there’s virtually no limit on the creativity you can blend into your home!

Roundtop vs. Archtop

Also included in the category of geometric windows, the key characteristic with either the Roundtop or Archtop window is the curvature.  Depending on the manufacturer, these terms might be used interchangeably due to their use of radius shaping, but for this round, we’re going to address them separately. 

Often referred to as a semi-circle or half-round, the roundtop window is iconic in its appearance and has been used in various architectural applications since the Roman Empire, approximately 700 BC.  These days, it’s primarily popular in the U.S. and also used in combination with a number of other window configurations, such as double-hung windows, casement windows and even patio doors.  The Half Round Window from Simonton is a great example of this particular shape.   

A variation on the roundtop is the archtop.  The NorthEast Windows Arch Top not only has various configurations of the arch design, but an equally versatile collection of grid patterns to create a truly unique impression… from gothic to contemporary. 

Winner: Too close to call.

BONUS ROUND: Sliding Patio Door vs. Hinged Patio Door

We would be remiss if we didn’t include a door or two in our competition.  Both variations on the same design, this duo brings an air of sophistication to any home.

For the perfect combo of class and utility, the sliding patio door with a French handle is a great addition if frequent access to the outdoors is the primary goal.  The elegant handle is only outmatched by the smooth operation which will come in handy over years of use.

If you have the space, why not consider a hinged patio door?  Available as an inswing or outswing, the classic effect of a hinged door can be felt every time you open and close it.  

Winner: We’ll have to deliberate on that one for a bit, but you probably know which one you prefer. 

Whew!  If you have ANY questions about any of these fabulous products, just reach out to us and we can create a plan for your project that you can feel confident about.